Skip to Content Skip to Subnavigation

OBSI – Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments

Consumer Portal LoginFirm Portal Login
Français
Increase Contrast
Fran�aisFR Main menu icon Open Menu
  • For Consumers
    • Can OBSI Help?
    • Consumer Bulletins
    • Consumer Portal
    • Consumer Resources
    • FAQs
    • Find Your Firm
    • How the Complaint Process Works
    • How We're Funded
    • Make a Complaint
    • Past Feedback and Input
    • Video Library
    • What to Expect for Consumers

    View our Make a Complaint page

    Make a Complaint

  • For Firms
    • Apply for Membership
    • Fee Payment Structure
    • Firm Bulletins
    • Firm Feedback and Input
    • Firm Helpdesk
    • Firm Portal
    • Firm Resources
    • Participating Firms
    • What to Expect for Firms

    Log in to OBSI Firm Portal

    Firm Login

  • How We Work
    • FAQs
    • Our Approaches
    • Our Service Standards
    • Outreach to Consumers and Firms
    • Reconsiderations and Complaints About OBSI
    • Responsibilities of Firms and Consumers
    • What to Expect From Our Process

    View our FAQs page

    FAQs

  • Case Data and Insights
    • Banking Case Summaries
    • Case Studies
    • Data Cube
    • Quarterly Case Data

    View our Case Studies page

    Case Studies

  • News and Publications
    • Annual Reports
    • Firm Refusals
    • News Releases
    • OBSI News
    • Presentations, Reports and Submissions
    • Print Materials
    • Public Consultations
    • Video Library

    View our OBSI News page

    OBSI News

  • About Us
    • About OBSI
    • Accessibility
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
    • Governance
    • How We're Regulated
    • Our History
    • Our Vision
    • Privacy
    • Staff
    • Terms of Reference

    View our Contact Us page

    Contact Us

I'd Like To... Open icon Close Icon
  • Make a complaint
  • Contact OBSI
  • Find my firm
  • Apply for membership
  • Know how the complaint process works
  • Learn more about OBSI's outreach to consumers and firms
  • Subscribe
  • Follow OBSI on Twitter
  • Follow OBSI on LinkedIn

bookshelf

Consumer’s intentions to gift money while alive could not be confirmed

Print Print link
Share Share icon
  • Open new window to share this page via Facebook Facebook
  • Open new window to share this page via LinkedIn LinkedIn
  • Open new window to share this page via Twitter Twitter
  • Email this page Email
Increase link Increase text size
Descrease link Decrease text size
Back to Search

Ms. A was a senior with serious health issues who had given one of her three daughters Power of Attorney (POA). Ms. A’s daughter arranged a time for them to meet with Mr. G who was Ms. A’s long-standing mutual fund representative at her bank branch.

On the day of the meeting, Ms. A’s daughter attended alone because Ms. A wanted to rest at home. Her daughter told Mr. G that the purpose of the meeting was to transfer Ms. A’s savings to her chequing account and liquidate her mutual funds. The daughter believed that it was her mother’s intention to divide the proceeds of the mutual funds equally between her and her sisters.

Without calling Ms. A to confirm her wishes, Mr. G acted on the daughter’s request to move Ms. A’s savings to Ms. A’s chequing account and sell the mutual funds in Ms. A’s investment account. The daughter told Mr. G that the cash proceeds of over a million dollars should be divided into three bank drafts – one for her and each of her sisters. They agreed to meet the following week, so the daughter could pick up the bank drafts at the branch.

Unexpectedly, the daughter had to postpone the meeting. When she called to reschedule, she was referred to Ms. Z, Mr. G’s colleague, because he was out of the office. The daughter had never met Ms. Z before, and Ms. Z had no prior knowledge of Ms. A’s account. During the meeting, Ms. Z expressed concerns about producing the bank drafts without Ms. A’s written consent in the file and escalated the matter.

Over the next several weeks, the bank sought legal advice. It had been unable to obtain consent for the transfers from Ms. A because she was undergoing medical treatment. Additionally, Mr. G was no longer employed at the bank.

Soon after, Ms. A died with the matter unresolved. As a result, the proceeds in Ms. A’s investment account were included in her estate and subject to probate fees. The probate fees of the estate were assessed at approximately $17,000. When her daughter requested reimbursement of these fees from the bank, the bank refused.

Complaint not upheld

During our investigation, we spoke to Ms. A’s daughter and representatives of the bank. We reviewed the outcome of the bank’s investigation, documentation for Ms. A’s investment account and a copy of Ms. A’s power of attorney. We found no independent evidence to confirm Ms. A’s intention to gift her investment proceeds to her daughters prior to death.

As Ms. A’s attorney under the POA, her daughter was legally required to manage Ms. A’s property in her best interest, which typically does not include the gifting of money to others. When Ms. A’s daughter requested that the bank prepare the documentation to give her mother’s money to her and her sisters, she was in a conflict of interest between her mother’s interests and her own.

After reviewing the evidence, we found that the bank had acted reasonably in requesting instructions directly from Ms. A, and when she was not available, had acted in a timely manner to determine how to proceed. After completing our investigation, we concluded that the bank had acted reasonably in the circumstances and there was no basis for compensation.

Subscribe to this Page
Subscribe
  • Can OBSI Help?
  • Consumer Bulletins
  • Consumer Portal
  • Consumer Resources
  • FAQs
  • Find Your Firm
  • How the Complaint Process Works
  • How We're Funded
  • Make a Complaint
  • Past Feedback and Input
  • Video Library
  • What to Expect for Consumers
  • For Consumers
  • For Firms
  • How We Work
  • Case Data and Insights
  • News and Publications
  • About Us
  • Other Links
  • Can OBSI Help?
  • Consumer Bulletins
  • Consumer Portal
  • Consumer Resources
  • FAQs
  • Find Your Firm
  • View All...
  • Apply for Membership
  • Fee Payment Structure
  • Firm Bulletins
  • Firm Feedback and Input
  • Firm Helpdesk
  • Firm Portal
  • View All...
  • FAQs
  • Our Approaches
  • Our Service Standards
  • Outreach to Consumers and Firms
  • Reconsiderations and Complaints About OBSI
  • Responsibilities of Firms and Consumers
  • View All...
  • Banking Case Summaries
  • Case Studies
  • Data Cube
  • Quarterly Case Data
  • Annual Reports
  • Firm Refusals
  • News Releases
  • OBSI News
  • Presentations, Reports and Submissions
  • Print Materials
  • View All...
  • About OBSI
  • Accessibility
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Governance
  • How We're Regulated
  • View All...
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • Accessibility
  • Subscribe to Our News
  • Contact Us
  • Website Feedback
  • View All...

Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments logo

Toll-Free Telephone: 1 (888) 451-4519
Greater Toronto Area: (416) 287-2877
TTY Telephone: 1 (844) 358-3442

Toll-Free Fax: 1 (888) 422-2865
Greater Toronto Area Fax: (416) 225-4722

Design by eSolutionsGroup

© 2017 Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments (OBSI), 20 Queen Street West, Suite 2400, P.O. Box 8, Toronto ON M5H 3R3

High Contrast Mode is on

Browser Compatibility Notification

It appears you are trying to access this site using an outdated browser. As a result, parts of the site may not function properly for you. We recommend updating your browser to its most recent version at your earliest convenience.