Close
Close
Browser Compatibility Notification
It appears you are trying to access this site using an outdated browser. As a result, parts of the site may not function properly for you. We recommend updating your browser to its most recent version at your earliest convenience.
Skip to Content Skip to Subnavigation

OBSI – Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments

Consumer Portal LoginFirm Portal Login
Français
Increase Contrast
Fran�aisFR Main menu icon Open Menu
  • For Consumers
    • Can OBSI Help?
    • Consumer Bulletins
    • Consumer Portal
    • Consumer Resources
    • FAQs
    • Find Your Firm
    • How the Complaint Process Works
    • How We're Funded
    • Make a Complaint
    • Past Feedback and Input

    View our Make a Complaint page

    Make a Complaint

  • For Firms
    • Apply for Membership
    • Fee Payment Structure
    • Firm Bulletins
    • Firm Feedback and Input
    • Firm Helpdesk
    • Firm Portal
    • Firm Resources
    • Membership Resources
    • Participating Firms

    Log in to OBSI Firm Portal

    Firm Login

  • How We Work
    • FAQs
    • OBSI and the Legal System
    • Our Approaches
    • Our Process
    • Our Service Standards
    • Our Vision, Mission and Values
    • Principles and Practice
    • Reconsiderations and Complaints About OBSI
    • Responsibilities of Firms and Consumers

    View our FAQs page

    FAQs

  • Case Data and Insights
    • Case Data
    • Case Studies

    View our Case Studies page

    Case Studies

  • News and Publications
    • Annual Reports
    • Firm Refusals
    • Media Releases
    • OBSI News
    • Presentations, Reports and Submissions
    • Print Materials
    • Public Consultations

    View our OBSI News page

    OBSI News

  • About Us
    • About OBSI
    • Accessibility
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
    • COVID-19 Update
    • Governance
    • How We're Regulated
    • Our History
    • Privacy
    • Staff
    • Strategic Plan
    • Terms of Reference

    View our Contact Us page

    Contact Us

I'd Like To... Open icon Close Icon
  • Make a complaint
  • Contact OBSI
  • Find my firm
  • Apply for membership
  • Log in to the Consumer Portal
  • Log in to the Firm Portal
  • Know how the complaint process works
  • Subscribe
  • Follow OBSI on Twitter
  • Follow OBSI on LinkedIn

Case Studies

HomeHow We Work
Print Print link
Share Share icon
  • Open new window to share this page via Facebook Facebook
  • Open new window to share this page via LinkedIn LinkedIn
  • Open new window to share this page via Twitter Twitter
  • Email this page Email
Increase link Increase text size
Descrease link Decrease text size

Investors incur significant losses and seek compensation, believing themselves to be unsuitably invested in high-risk securities

Posted Tuesday November 10, 2020

Category: Unsuitable Investments

Key lessons:

  • Investment suitability is not determined on the basis of losses. Investment suitability is based on the risk profile of an investment at the time that advice about it was given.
  • Every investment has the possibility of gains and the risk of loss, and the amount of each is usually closely matched. The advisor’s role is to recommend suitable investments, but they cannot predict the future nor guarantee results.
  • Investors should monitor their investments and stay informed by reviewing their account statements regularly. If you are concerned about the performance of your investments, you should contact your investment advisor to discuss the matter.

Investment losses lead consumers to challenge suitability

Mr. and Mrs. E, a married couple who operated their own business, purchased securities in their Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs) and joint account. When they first met with their investment advisor, Mr. and Mrs. E agreed they had a medium to medium-high risk tolerance. While they were experienced investors, Mr. and Mrs. E still relied on their advisor to recommend suitable investments for them.

Over an eight-month period beginning January 2018, Mr. and Mrs. E’s advisor recommended that they invest in certain public company shares and carried out these purchases in their accounts. Although their monthly account statements began to show losses, Mr. and Mrs. E had incurred losses on other investments before and were optimistic that the shares would recover. When this did not happen and their loss reached $47,000, Mr. and Mrs. E concluded that their investments must have been high-risk because they had lost a significant amount of money.

Firm confirms investment met risk tolerance

Mr. and Mrs. E contacted the firm in the fall of 2019 with their concerns about being unsuitably invested. They complained that, because they were preoccupied with operating their business, they had only recently become aware of their losses on the shares. Mr. and Mrs. E believed that the shares were a high-risk investment that went beyond their risk tolerance and asked the firm to compensate them for their entire loss of $47,000.

The firm investigated their complaint and found that the shares were within Mr. and Mrs. E’s risk tolerance. Consequently, the firm refused to compensate Mr. and Mrs. E.

Dissatisfied with this outcome, Mr. and Mrs. E brought their complaint to OBSI.

Our findings

During our investigation, we spoke to Mr. and Mrs. E and their advisor and we reviewed their account opening documents, correspondence, and other documentation in the firm’s file. We also conducted a detailed analysis of the investments in their accounts. We found that:

  • The shares that they had purchased were a medium-risk investment at the time that Mr. and Mrs. E’s advisor purchased it on their behalf, making it a suitable investment for them.
  • All of Mr. and Mrs. E’s other investments were suitable, including the shares that had lost value.
  • Mr. and Mrs. E had experienced a significant loss due to market volatility, not because they were unsuitably invested.

The outcome

We had no basis to recommend compensation, and we explained our findings in detail to Mr. and Mrs. E.

Back to News
Subscribe




debit card fraud

Consumer responsible for unauthorized transactions after not taking enough care to protect his debit card and PIN

Posted Friday, February 26, 2021

fraud

Bank customer is a victim of multiple incidents of fraud

Posted Friday, December 18, 2020

investment suitability

Investors incur significant losses and seek compensation, believing themselves to be unsuitably invested in high-risk securities

Posted Tuesday, November 10, 2020

mortgage

Bank errors when arranging a mortgage transfer lead to costly penalties for borrower

Posted Monday, August 31, 2020

  • FAQs
  • OBSI and the Legal System
  • Our Approaches
  • Our Process
  • Our Service Standards
  • Our Vision, Mission and Values
  • Principles and Practice
  • Reconsiderations and Complaints About OBSI
  • Responsibilities of Firms and Consumers
  • For Consumers
  • For Firms
  • How We Work
  • Case Data and Insights
  • News and Publications
  • About Us
  • Other Links
  • Can OBSI Help?
  • Consumer Bulletins
  • Consumer Portal
  • Consumer Resources
  • FAQs
  • Find Your Firm
  • View All...
  • Apply for Membership
  • Fee Payment Structure
  • Firm Bulletins
  • Firm Feedback and Input
  • Firm Helpdesk
  • Firm Portal
  • View All...
  • FAQs
  • OBSI and the Legal System
  • Our Approaches
  • Our Process
  • Our Service Standards
  • Our Vision, Mission and Values
  • View All...
  • Case Data
  • Case Studies
  • Annual Reports
  • Firm Refusals
  • Media Releases
  • OBSI News
  • Presentations, Reports and Submissions
  • Print Materials
  • View All...
  • About OBSI
  • Accessibility
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • COVID-19 Update
  • Governance
  • View All...
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • Accessibility
  • Subscribe to Our News
  • Contact Us
  • Website Feedback
  • View All...

Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments logo

Toll-Free Telephone: 1 (888) 451-4519
Greater Toronto Area: (416) 287-2877
TTY Telephone: 1 (855) TTY-OBSI

Toll-Free Fax: 1 (888) 422-2865
Greater Toronto Area Fax: (416) 225-4722

Design by eSolutionsGroup

© 2017 Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments (OBSI), 20 Queen Street West, Suite 2400, P.O. Box 8, Toronto ON M5H 3R3

High Contrast Mode is on